arrow_backBack to Hotel
HotelstarstarstarverifiedVerified Reviews

Fairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites New York Manhattan/Central Park

4.1starstarstarstarstar(500+)
Premium
location_on538 W 58th St, New York, New York, 10019

What Guests Say

comfortable bed (35)clean bathroom (10)broken elevators (6)
trending_up
Premium
Score: 38/100

Premium tier — higher price point with corresponding quality.

Guest Reviews

Janak Joshistarstarstarstar2026-03-04T21:17:04

"Your generic Fairfield Inn in a good location, predictable service and room quality and a cute little cozy bar and sitting area in the lobby. Customer service is generic/predictable/binary to Fairfield Standards. Few things - can YOU please stop playing loud trashy American pop music in the lobby a"

Elvirucca Fiorinistarstarstarstar2025-11-10T05:20:28

"This hotel is very safe. Everyone is very accommodating, and they go above and beyond to answer all of the questions you have. The service for the rooms are quite good. They dont give you a lot in the rooms (soaps and toilet paper) and you have to be really specific to them on what you want. Overall"

ROBERTO MENDOZAstarstarstarstar2026-01-15T19:56:53

"The hotel is ok as expected for a Fairfield Inn (super small rooms, understandable for NYC) and feels very safe. Rooms are clean ok, bed is comfortable. Heater in the room is extremely loud (like I read in other reviews) and the bathroom is not heated, so you really need to close the bathroom door"

Duna Degross Toddstarstar2026-01-18T16:05:57

"About 11-13 minute walk from the subway station. If you are planning on taking the subway everywhere. This might not be the place for you. Lots of druggies on the way from the subway to the hotel because of how secluded the hotel is. Rooms were clean but very very small. The cleaner was very rude. S"

Justin Moorestarstarstarstar2026-01-10T05:17:56

"Great value and quiet location that's a ~10 min. walk from Columbus Circle. Free hot breakfast was a nice perk, which went til 9:30 on the weekend (another bonus). Eggs, waffles, sausage, bagels, fruit, cereals, etc. Several solid food options within very short walking distance as well, like The Gre"

About

Across the street from the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, this relaxed redbrick hotel is a 9-minute walk from the nearest subway station and a 10-minute walk from Central Park. Streamlined rooms offer free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, plus minifridges and coffeemakers; some add city views. Complimentary hot breakfast is served in a casual breakfast room with cityscape murals. There's also a polished lobby bar, a gym and a furnished terrace.

photo_cameraFairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites New York Manhattan/Central Park

Review Keywords

elevators (256)room size (86)proximity to times square (59)comfortable bed (35)slow elevators (33)luggage space (31)proximity to the subway (25)elevator wait times (15)clean bathroom (10)broken elevators (6)

Amenities

Free Wi-FiFree breakfastAccessibleAir-conditionedBusiness centerKid-friendlyRestaurantFitness centerBarSmoke-free
warning

Low Dissatisfaction Risk

9% of reviews indicate dissatisfaction — in line with expectations for this category.

Rating Distribution

5star
892
4star
535
3star
192
2star
81
1star
126