arrow_backBack to Hotel
HotelstarstarstarstarverifiedVerified Reviews

The Carnegie Hotel

4.5starstarstarstarstar(500+)
Average
location_on160 W 56th St, New York, New York, 10019

What Guests Say

modern rooms (12)comfortable bed (11)quiet room (5)
trending_up
Average
Score: 41/100

Average value — pricing aligns with market expectations.

Guest Reviews

Noah Huistarstarstarstarstar2026-01-25T17:32:15

"Excellent value for money for its location in NYC. Small building wedged between a few others however the room was outstanding. Comfortable, clean, and well maintained. Breakfast and wine and cheese hour included in the rate which was also nice. Breakfast selection is limited (considering the size o"

Nora Huntstarstarstarstarstar2026-03-01T21:41:01

"My mother visited me in the city and stayed here. Perfect location with the subway and a lot of great restaurants nearby, plus Central Park two blocks away. The staff was always so friendly and the room was quiet, updated, and comfortable."

Sheldon Erbstarstarstarstarstar2025-11-13T01:05:25

"First impression was impressive with the staff that stood, smiled, and greeted me upon arrival. Followed by a complementary glass of wine and fruit/cheese/nuts. The room was modern, very quiet, and comfortable. Only 4-5 rooms per floor. Finishes inside were well-appointed, great attention to det"

korra dalestarstarstarstarstar2026-02-12T18:31:49

"Just wrapped up a stay at The Carnegie Hotel and really enjoyed it! The location is absolutely perfect, right where you want to be. The rooms were pretty solid - clean and comfortable, exactly what I needed after a day out. Service was great too, super friendly and helpful staff all around. Definite"

George Drastalstarstarstarstarstar2025-11-11T16:28:24

"The staff was helpful and the room was excellent. Breakfast every morning was free and above average for a self-service type. Coffee, tea, hot chocolate was available there all day. The location could hardly be better, especially if you're planning to attend events at Carnegie, or Lincoln Center."

About

A 3-minute walk from Carnegie Hall, this sleek, music-themed hotel is also a minute's walk from a subway station and a mile from the Empire State Building. Chic rooms with striking murals come with free Wi-Fi, 40-inch flat-screen TVs and iPod docks, plus minifridges and designer toiletries. Room service is available. A breakfast buffet, regular evening socials and access to a nearby health club are complimentary. Valet parking is offered for a surcharge.

photo_cameraThe Carnegie Hotel

Review Keywords

room size (36)proximity to times square (30)modern rooms (12)comfortable bed (11)free snacks (9)boutique hotel (8)subway access (7)no gym (6)free wine (5)quiet room (5)

Amenities

Free Wi-FiFree breakfastPaid parkingAccessibleAir-conditionedKid-friendlySmoke-free
warning

Low Dissatisfaction Risk

4% of reviews indicate dissatisfaction — in line with expectations for this category.

Rating Distribution

5star
385
4star
96
3star
28
2star
6
1star
18