The Garden City Hotel
What Guests Say
Average value — pricing aligns with market expectations.
Guest Reviews
"I recently visited the hotel for my bday and the experience was great. After my massage I had lunch at the restaurant upstairs. The bartender Kevin was amazing!!!!!! 10/10 service, super funny and attentive. Best Lon drops in town. He deserves a huge raise for his kind and generous demeanor. I will"
"Always a great stay. I only stay at the Garden City hotel when I come to Long Island. The best part of the stay/hotel is the staff. They always make you feel welcomed. Anthony and the team at check in are amazing. Have to recognize Jessica, too, but everyone is great!"
"I came here for a getaway for the weekend and my expectations were blown away. The hotel was luxurious and the service was impeccable. Me and wife's needs were always met by the warm and friendly staff. We arrived to the room to delicious desserts and drinks and instantly felt like home. The hotel w"
"We hosted our parents' 50th Anniversary Lunch for 25 at the Red Salt Room. It was a wonderful experience from start to finish. The valet parking was essential for the crowd. The room is on the main lobby area (no stairs) and the food was fantastic. Most of all the service and staff were unbeliev"
"Me and my wife stayed here for our 11th year wedding anniversary and from the time I booked until we left nothing but top notch service from the complementary valet parking to room service and daily follow ups. The room was very clean and well maintained I have not one bad feed back. We will be back"
About
This old-world-style luxury hotel is in a historic property that dates from 1874; it's a 1-minute walk from the Long Island Railroad and 19 miles from Manhattan. The posh rooms have flat-screen TVs, Italian furniture, Wi-Fi (surcharge) and 24-hour room service. Upgraded suites add kitchenettes and living areas, while some feature an additional bathroom and private outdoor patios. Perks include 25,000 sq ft of event space, an indoor pool, a spa and sauna, a fitness center and an upscale steakhouse, plus a seasonal patio bar, and lounge. Pet walking and feeding services are available. Parking is
Review Keywords
Amenities
Low Dissatisfaction Risk
7% of reviews indicate dissatisfaction — in line with expectations for this category.
Rating Distribution
Nearby Properties
Other accommodations within 2 km.
At a Glance
- Category
- Hotel
- Total Reviews
- 500+
- Amenities
- 15
- On Map
- View