The Gatsby Hotel

"It's an older hotel that seems to have been renovated, but the issues remain. I was placed in two different rooms, and neither had working hot water. I would only consider staying here as a last resort"

"My husband and I visit NYC once a year and have stayed in a lot of different hotels (chain & boutique) as well as Airbnb in different areas. This was one of the worst. The website states there is a safe, iHome clock with charger, free WiFi. When we checked in we had to pay a $17.21 fee which we were"

"This was by far the worst hotel experience I've ever had. Twice, staff left our room door open -- a serious security risk, confirmed on their own cameras. The room was dirty, smelled of humidity, and wasn't properly cleaned the next day. The toilet didn't flush correctly, making it nearly unusable. "

"The hotel charged a $50 service fee that was not clearly disclosed in advance during the agency booking. In addition, the hot water was not functioning properly; staff advised me to wait 10-15 minutes, which did resulted in unnecessary water waste. I was assigned a basement room with no natural lig"

"Stayed here for 3 nights, there was an issue with the heater and they two lovely receptionists were able get it fixed up for me & include another heater just in case which was fantastic! This area is particularly busy and you will hear everything that's happening on the street. Sirens and beeping ar"