The Yellowstone Forest Hills
What Guests Say
Average value — pricing aligns with market expectations.
Guest Reviews
"Living in this "luxury" building was far from luxurious. We moved out a few months ago and felt it was important to share our honest experience for others considering renting here. Overall, we found the building significantly overpriced given the ongoing issues we encountered. 1. Although manageme"
"Moved out after 1 year living here. PLEASE stay away! It was my worst living experience in +10 years in NYC 1. NOT SAFE: anyone can walk in. Half the tenants are section 8. Open drug use in common space despite management putting up sign that say No Drug Use 2. NOT SOUNDPROOF: neighbor's music blas"
"Update as of 9/12/25: We moved out of the building on 7/30/25. We did not receive our security deposit until 9/10/25. According to NYC housing guidelines, security deposits must be returned within 14 days after the tenants move out. Nobody responded to our emails or calls in the office, of course. "
"So glad that I only signed a 1-year lease so I could escape this place. Even 1 year was too long considering all the problems. I had been too scared to post this review until I received my security deposit back. 0) Rolling blinds for the windows were installed after we signed the lease. One of our "
"I recently moved here and so far I've been loving it! Traders Joe's is right downstairs which is a life saver!!!! My apartment has beautiful finishes and the building is very clean."
About
Urban Style. Suburban Living. Nestled in the idyllic urban village of Forest Hills Gardens, The Yellowstone Apartments embody a blend of sophisticated living and a unique enclave amid a bustling city. Offering a distinctive sensibility, beauty and charm, the Yellowstone Apartments have been designed to perfectly integrate with this special neighborhood. Cool tones and a sense of serenity permeate the attended, marble lobby while the contemporary apartments and a wide variety of indoor and outdoor amenities -including an attended lobby, fitness center and roof deck to enhance daily life.
Review Keywords
Moderate Dissatisfaction Risk
38% of reviews indicate dissatisfaction — above average for this category.
Rating Distribution
Nearby Properties
Other accommodations within 2 km.
At a Glance
- Category
- Apartment Guest Stay
- Total Reviews
- 10+
- Amenities
- 0
- On Map
- View